The Breakdown: Godspeed, Johan
Despite all the goings-on in the world right now — the presidential campaigning, the Super Bowl, the writers strike, female celebrities’ ongoing underwear boycott and more — the only thing on the minds of many of us Minnesotans is today’s trade of Johan Santana. The best pitcher in baseball, not to mention the best in Twins history, is gone. For now, that is all that matters.
As for my thoughts on the trade, I’ll admit upfront that I know very little of the Mets prospects dealt to the Twins. Initial thinking is that they’re four of the top seven prospects in the Mets organization; each guy is young and each has delivered above-average minor league seasons thus far. Chances are at least a couple of them will be solid players someday. But that’s the extent of my knowledge. So, all you’re getting from me now is a gut reaction.
I don’t like it. I don’t like this trade for the same reason Santana rightfully expressed his displeasure in the team’s organization last season: because the Twins are always playing for the future. They seemingly refuse to play for today, and I don’t seen an end to that trend.
As disheartening as it sounds, my main worry is when one of these prospects turns into something special, the Twins will go ahead and trade him away for yet more prospects. And so on it will go, where we play with the hopes of maybe, possibly, if all goes right, fingers crossed, we could someday hopefully find a way to sneak into the playoffs. I’d love to think that one of these years, the Twins will hold on to their studs and take a strong two- or three-year run at the Series. But if not this season, with this pitcher, then when? When will the management stop trading the all-stars away and actually make a push?
As far as the general population’s reaction to the trade, I’m betting most optimists will point to the past Twins star-for-prospects trades and suggest being patient. They’ll reference the players we got in return that panned out and became something special. Normally, I’d agree. Unloading one talented guy when the team isn’t going anywhere to begin with is the logical move. That’s why we lost Knoblauch, and Aguilera, and Viola before him, and probably countless others I’m forgetting. Those moves were inevitable.
But this time around, the Twins don’t need to be in rebuilding mode. They’ve got a competitive squad set to take the field in ’08, and were just a couple shrewd free agent signings away from having just as good a chance as anyone to win it all. But now, by losing the best pitcher in the game in exchange for four unproven prospects, that potential is gone. We’re back to square one, starting over with a few established stars, a couple over-the-hill vets and a plethora of youngsters.
Just like in the past, we’re playing for the future. It’s deja vu all over again.

(Warning: most of these stories are outdated by about a week. Sorry. Also: heavy on snark. Let us blame the percoset for that one, mkay?)
Three recent stories have helped to confirm my long-standing assertion that Derek Jeter is a vastly overrated player. Let’s walk through these step-by-step:

Recent Comments